Like magic, the signature synth line has become a tasteful acoustic guitar. Alex Van Halen’s pounding drums have been replaced by what is either a drum machine, or a drummer so lifeless and rote he might as well be one. David Lee Roth’s infantile yelping has morphed into stately Scottish sad sack smoothery. How could two songs be more opposite? Different words wouldn’t help. Opposites are always similar in basic ways. There’s a reason the opposite of “love” isn’t “knife”. Only another strong emotion will do.
As long as copies of the original song exist, there are very few reasons to listen to this version apart from 1) a purely academic examination of what makes a thing a thing and another thing another thing and not a thing, or 2) to piss off, say, a maternal uncle, or a mechanic, or some other VH enthusiast.
It’s a good thing this track exists, though. If, God forbid, something should happen to all the digital and physical copies of 1984 and all the “Jump” cassingles, we could end up with a passable copy of the original if we fed this version into an Aztec Camera.
I like this because it seems free from irony. Have you ever heard Mark Kozelek's AC/DC covers? Like that. Perfect.
ReplyDeleteYeah, it's refreshingly sincere, just like the Kozelek covers. Unless, of course, the Scottish have developed a new kind of irony based on excessive sincerity.
ReplyDeleteDamn the Scottish and their new developments in sarcasm!
ReplyDeleteThis an example how to turn an upbeat good time song into a dirge.
ReplyDeleteYou say that like it's a bad thing.
ReplyDeleteThis is a great sincere cover that wasn't done for laughs. It's pleasing and nice.
ReplyDelete